"A World Appears: A Journey into Consciousness," by Michael Pollan

 A World Appears by Michael Pollan


by 
793473
's review
 ·  edit

it was ok
bookshelves: philosophy, science

Consciousness, what is it? This is the question that this book strives to answer. At one level it’s an ordinary word that everyone knows what it means. But what is the source of the internal private experience that we perceive to be consciousness? If one tries to define it by various observable properties the question shifts to who or what has it or doesn’t have it. The question is becoming more prescient with AI’s arrival. If artificial intelligence is skilled at acting as if it has consciousness, does it have it?

Most neuroscientists think of consciousness being the physical interaction of many billions of brain neurons. But exactly how do they interactively communicate to create an internal sense of awareness of existence? Even if scientists could utilize billions of computer chips, how to connect them in order to create consciousness is still a mystery.

There are many theories of consciousness—as many as twenty-two—and I don't think the author addressed them all, but it seemed as if he did. Theories varied from all life (single cell life to mammals) have a bit of consciousness to the other extreme of no life having consciousness (throughout universe outside of life). These extreme views are hard to take seriously, but one thing from the book that I’m pondering is the idea that perhaps consciousness can’t be understood because we can’t get outside of conscious life in order to objectively study consciousness from its exterior. Huh?

Pollan does a good job reviewing what all the experts say on the subject. The problem is that experts can’t agree on a definition. Thus any discussion of consciousness is subjective in nature and this book ends up sounding like a transcript of a bull-session of want-to-be philosophers arguing about what is truth. It’s a bunch of talk and theories with no conclusive answer. My interest in the subject wandered as I plodded thru this book’s quagmire of subjective speculation. Thus the two stars. It's not Pollan's writing that's the problem, it's the subject. 

The book title reminds me of the experience of a newborn baby. The baby opens their eyes for the first time and “a world appears.” But the same thing happens to all of us when we wakeup from a night's sleep; we open our eyes and a world appears.


READING PROGRESS

December 24, 2025 – Shelved
September 1, 2026 – Started Reading
September 3, 2026 – Finished Reading

COMMENTS  Showing 1-2 of 2

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 1: by Tony

Tony SunderlandVery perceptive last Paragraph Clif!

reply | delete | flag

Clif HostetlerTony wrote: "Very perceptive last Paragraph Clif!"

It's the simple things that are overlooked.

reply | edit | delete | flag

back to top



    (preview)
  *




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Calamity Club, by Kathryn Stockett

Aging Out, by Lucy Schiller

The Correspondent, by Virginia Evans